By Austin Cory Bart acbart@vt.edu, Joung Min Choi joungmin@vt.edu, Bo Guan jasonguan0107@vt.edu Version 3.0.0, created 10/5/2021 Tags: us, usa, united states, government, law, legal, court, case, supreme, judge, barrister, lawyer, federal, national
Overview
The U.S. Supreme Court Database traces its history back about two decades ago, when Harold J. Spaeth asked the National Science Foundation to fund a database that would be so rich in content that multiple users - even those with vastly distinct projects and purposes in mind - could draw on it. Professor Spaeth's goal was at once refreshingly simple and extremely ambitious: to produce a database that would include and classify every single vote by a Supreme Court justice in all argued cases over a five-decade period. After securing the funding, Spaeth collected and coded the data, performed reliability checks, and eventually amassed the Database. In the late 1980s, he made it (and the documentation necessary to use it) publicly available.
Since then, Professor Spaeth has not only updated it each term; he has also continued to perform reliability analyses, thereby ensuring its integrity with each release, and added new variables. Today's version of the Database houses 247 pieces of information for each case, roughly broken down into six categories: (1) identification variables (e.g., citations and docket numbers); (2) background variables (e.g., how the Court took jurisdiction, origin and source of the case, the reason the Court agreed to decide it); (3) chronological variables (e.g., the date of decision, term of Court, natural court); (4) substantive variables (e.g., legal provisions, issues, direction of decision); (5) outcome variables (e.g., disposition of the case, winning party, formal alteration of precedent, declaration of unconstitutionality); and (6) voting and opinion variables (e.g., how the individual justices voted, their opinions and interagreements).
Case Centered data provides case level information; i.e., each row in the database corresponds to a dispute. These data do not contain specific justice vote information.
the citation to each case from the United States Reports(LEd)
"lexis"
str
"1946 U.S. LEXIS 1724"
the citation to each case from the LEXIS cite
"sct"
str
"67 S. Ct. 6"
the citation to each case from the Supreme Court Reporter (S.CT)
"us"
str
"329 U.S. 1"
the citation to each case from the official United States
Reports (US)
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"authority"
str
"4.0"
the bases on which the Supreme Court rested its decision with regard to each legal provision that the Court considered in the case
"direction"
str
"liberal"
the ideological "direction" of the decision to determine whether the Court supports or opposes the issue to which the case
pertains
"dissent agrees"
bool
True
whether the dissenting opinion and the majority in a case both support (1) or, conversely, oppose (0) the issue to which the case pertains
"jurisdiction"
str
"rehearing or restored to calendar for reargument"
a variety of means whereby the Court undertakes to consider cases that it has been petitioned to review
"precedent altered?"
bool
True
whether the majority opinion effectively says that the decision in this case "overruled" one or more of the Court's own precedents
"term"
int
1946
the term in which the Court handed down its decision
"type"
str
"opinion of the court (orally argued)"
the decision type the Court made for the case
"unconstitutional"
str
"no declaration of unconstitutionality"
whether the Court either declared unconstitutional an act of Congress; a state or territorial statute, regulation, or constitutional provision; or a municipal or other local ordinance
"winning party"
str
"petitioning party received a favorable disposition"
whether the petitioning party (i.e., the plaintiff or the appellant) emerged victorious
the first of four unique internal identification numbers
"case issues"
str
"1946-001-01-01"
the third of four unique internal identification numbers
"docket"
str
"1946-001-01"
the second of four unique internal identification numbers
"vote"
str
"1946-001-01-01-01"
the fourth of four unique internal identification numbers
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"area"
str
"Economic Activity"
This variable simply separates the issues identified in the preceding variable (issue) into the larger categories
"id"
int
80180
issue id
"text"
str
"patents and copyrights: patent"
the issue for each decision
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"id"
int
6
id for the law type
"type"
str
"Infrequently litigated statutes"
the constitutional provision(s), statute(s), or court rule(s) that the Court considered in the case
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"direction"
str
"conservative"
whether the decision of the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed was itself liberal or conservative as these terms are defined in the direction of decision variable
"disagreement?"
bool
True
the Supreme Court's majority opinion mentioned that one or more of the members of the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed dissented
"disposition"
str
"affirmed"
the treatment the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed accorded the decision of the court it reviewed
"reasons"
str
"to resolve question presented"
the reason, if any, that the Court gives for granting the petition for certiorari
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"chief"
str
"Vinson"
the chief justice during whose tenure the case was decided
"id"
int
1301
natural court id
"period"
int
1
a period during which no personnel change occurs
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"id"
int
51
origin id
"name"
str
"California Southern U.S. District Court"
the court in which the case originated, not the administrative agency
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"id"
int
29
source id
"name"
str
"U.S. Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit"
the court whose decision the Supreme Court reviewed
Key
Type
Example Value
Description
"majority"
int
8
the frequency with which given justices vote with the majority
"minority"
int
1
the number of votes in dissent
"split on second"
bool
True
whether the vote variables (e.g., majVotes, minVotes) pertain to the vote on the second issue